Read Nonfiction Journal
A research-driven review of nonfiction examining history, politics, economics, and the human condition.
Disclosure: Some articles may contain affiliate links. Editorial content is independent.
Topics
Why Do Nations Go to War? A Historical Inquiry
Introduction
This review examines *The Causes of the Civil War* (2008) by Paul Calore, a work that surveys the political, economic, cultural, and territorial disputes that contributed to sectional conflict in the United States. Rather than advancing a single interpretation, the book presents a structured overview of the competing forces that shaped the period leading up to war. It is particularly useful for readers seeking a broad framework of the issues rather than a narrowly argued thesis. The analysis below considers both the scope of the work and the depth of its treatment of these underlying causes.
Historical Patterns
Wars tend to follow recognizable patterns:
- Economic dislocation or inequality
- Political breakdown or sectional division
- Competing interpretations of law, sovereignty, or rights
- Elite decision-making disconnected from popular cost
The American Civil War illustrates all four. Long before
Literature & Scholarship
*The Causes of the Civil War: The Political, Cultural, Economic and Territorial Disputes between North and South* by Paul Calore provides a concise examination of the multiple forces that contributed to the outbreak of the American Civil War. The book is structured to guide readers through the principal areas of conflict, including disputes over tariffs, states’ rights, slavery, westward expansion, and the balance of political power between the North and South.
Rather than focusing exclusively on a single cause, Calore presents the Civil War as the result of intersecting pressures that developed over decades. Political disagreements over federal authority, economic divergence between industrial and agrarian systems, and cultural differences between regions are each treated as contributing elements within a broader framework. The book also addresses how territorial expansion intensified these tensions by repeatedly raising unresolved questions about the extension of slavery into new states.
Written in a clear and accessible style, the work serves as an introductory synthesis rather than a deeply specialized study. It is particularly suited for readers seeking an organized overview of the major arguments surrounding the origins of the Civil War, while leaving room for further exploration and interpretation.
Featured Book Review
This review examines a nonfiction work to understand how events, systems, and decisions shape real outcomes. The focus is on evidence, context, and competing interpretations rather than simplistic cause-and-effect narratives.
In The Causes of the Civil War: The Political, Cultural, Economic and Territorial Disputes between North and South, Paul Calore attempts to reduce the complex origins of sectional conflict to an accessible synthesis of political, economic, cultural, and territorial disputes that accumulated over more than a century before 1861. Calore traces a wide range of drivers—including the impact of slavery, economic protectionism, territorial expansion, and shifting political alignments—as interconnected forces that heightened antagonism between North and South and set the stage for disunion.
Calore’s narrative covers major topics in antebellum sectional tension: from the legacy of slavery and early abolitionism to tariff debates, the Bank War, and expansionist contests over land and settlement, through the vitality of the Kansas–Nebraska controversies and the political realignments of the 1850s. By organizing these disputes in sequence, Calore highlights how multiple lines of conflict—economic and cultural as well as political—became cumulatively difficult to reconcile.
As a primer for readers new to Civil War origins, the book is thorough in scope, moving from late-eighteenth-century sectional formation into the immediate crisis of secession. The chronology and chapter structure provide useful framing for non-specialists seeking a broad overview of contributing factors and how they interacted over time.
However, the book’s limitations become evident under closer analytical scrutiny. One notable choice is the absence of footnotes tied to specific claims, which can make it difficult to assess the evidentiary basis for particular interpretations or to trace Calore’s sources on contested points. While a bibliography is included, the lack of explicit sourcing weakens the work’s usefulness for readers seeking deeper engagement with primary materials or historiographical debate.
Additionally, while Calore acknowledges multiple strands of conflict, the work tends toward descriptive aggregation rather than analytical synthesis in the way leading academic treatments do. Calore’s treatment of some topics—for example, the rise and fall of abolitionism or the implications of economic protectionism—is useful as narrative summary, but it stops short of situating these developments within broader historiographical conversations about power, labor systems, and institutional pressures. Compared to deeply contextualized works by leading scholars, this limits the book’s contribution to advanced study.
In sum, The Causes of the Civil War serves well as an introductory mapping of major disputes that fed sectional antagonism. It lays out what happened and when, and provides a broad checklist of causes often discussed across Civil War literature. For readers who want a starting point for understanding the multiplicity of disputes between North and South, Calore’s synthesis offers a serviceable overview. For those seeking rigorous causal analysis grounded in historiographical debate and documented argumentation, it should be paired with more deeply sourced works.
Best for: Readers new to Civil War origins who want a broad outline of key disputes across political, economic, cultural, and territorial fronts before 1861.
Caveats: Limited source citation and analytical depth mean the book functions better as an overview than as a definitive causal study.
Conclusion
Wars are not accidents. They are outcomes. Understanding their causes requires patience, documentation, and a willingness to question simplified narratives—precisely what serious nonfiction should provide.
Amazon Associates notice: ReadNonFiction.com participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.
As an Amazon Associate, Lake Region Publishing LLC earns from qualifying purchases.
Disclosure: Lake Region Publishing LLC, owns and operates ReadNonFiction.com. This analysis is provided for informational purposes and should be interpreted as an independent third-party review.